December 12th, 2005 5:05am
Try To Live In A Lovelier Light
Fiona Apple @ Nokia Theatre, 12/11/2005
Get Him Back / Better Version Of Me / Shadowboxer / To Your Love / I Know / Sleep To Dream / Limp / Paper Bag / Tymps / Oh Well / On The Bound / Red, Red, Red / Not About Love / O’ Sailor / Get Gone / Fast As You Can // Extraordinary Machine / Criminal / Parting Gift
Fiona Apple “Not About Love” – Fiona Apple didn’t speak very much during this show, but when she did, she mostly talked about being nervous and worried. If you know a thing or two about Apple from over the years, this shouldn’t be so surprising, but in the context of a performance so incredibly assured and compelling, it’s a very curious thing. If she never said a word, it would all seem entirely effortless. She throws herself into every moment of every song, investing every lyric with the fullest of emotion, be it nuanced as in “I Know” (a song which ranks in the highest percentile of my favorite songs ever; I was feeling chills the entire time), or ferocious and raw as with the “Sleep To Dream”/”Limp” bitterness twofer. “Not About Love” was a particular highlight, with its heavy vamp feeling like fists to the gut, and a manic outro that barely felt tame in spite of the band’s obvious control. It blows my mind that a person could be among the best vocalists and songwriters of their generation and on top of that be drop dead gorgeous and still deal with crippling pangs of doubt, but I suppose we’re all better off with some humility.
(For other very OTM reviews of this show, please visit Tom Breihan’s Status Ain’t Hood and SF/J.)
It’s so unfortunate that the critical reaction to Extraordinary Machine ended up getting so badly muddled by a debate over the relative merits of the Jon Brion and Mike Elizondo versions. I maintain that the final product is better by far, but in any case, the basic quality of these songs remains the same, and the best record of 2005 ends up getting screwed over by vote-splitting. I’m sure that in the future, this album will earn the reputation that it deserves, but it absolutely vexes me to see it get passed over by many of my peers in favor of flimsy hackwork in the meantime. I suspect part of it is due to Apple’s subject matter. Writing brilliantly on the topic of love is hardly a fashionable thing – lord knows Stephin Merritt has to wrap up his projects in novelty just to get any serious attention at all. (Click here to buy it from Amazon.)
Destroyer “Sick Priest Learns To Last Forever” – A majority of the Destroyer catalog sounds best at night, but this track has the power to turn any moment of the day into the wee hours of the morning. It’s the perfect music for stumbling home in the cold, ready to fall over but still too far from your front door. It’s the sound of your stray thoughts echoing off the walls as you wait forever on the subway platform, barely keeping your eyes open, and the obscure lyrics start to make perfect sense if just because Dan Bejar is delivering them with such convinction. The sick priest learns to last forevah! Yeah, of course he does. Me too. (Click here for Merge’s Destroyer site.)