6/30/25
Love Is Never One Thing
Animal Collective “Love on the Big Screen”
I’ve noticed that as the Animal Collective guys get older they’ve become more generous about releasing catchy little songs. They’ve always had catchy little songs, but there’s a lot of phases where they’re clearly more interested in more experimental, less structured, and sometimes totally non-melodic music. Maybe they’re less interested in that these days, or perhaps they’ve just become more self-assured as songwriters. I think it’s mostly that they’ve figured out how to have it both ways over the past 10 years. If they’re doing a pop song, they’re never doing it any sort of normal way. It’s always a bit off-kilter, always unusual musical choices, always a little subversive. They’ve fully become who they’ve always been.
“Love on the Big Screen” has the bones of a bashed-out psychedelic garage rock song, but the actual arrangement is much more along the lines of the lo-fi home recordings of R. Stevie Moore or The Cleaners from Venus. (Also worth noting that it starts with the same drum machine loop as The Fiery Furnaces’ “Benton Harbor Blues.”) It’s immediately catchy in a radio jingle sort of way, but even with one of the biggest call-and-response vocal hooks of their 25+ year career, the music feels deliberately untethered and disorienting.
I like what Avey Tare is doing with the lyrics in this one. The premise is big and bold and obvious – love on the big screen isn’t like love in real life – but they push a few steps beyond simply stating a cliched notion. As with a lot of Animal Collective songs before it, it’s a meditation on the practical aspects of love. The lyrics seesaw between grand philosophical statements and expressions of uncertainty. The point being, love contains a lot of contradictions that can’t be flattened into a simple narrative, or a single song. And it’s different for everyone! We can try to capture some of it, but it’s always just a few facets at a time.
Buy it from Bandcamp.