I didn’t see every artist at the festival, and I didn’t see all of most of the sets that I saw, but here are my thoughts, impressions, observations, etc.
Slint – Spiderland was more of a background thing for me, though I made sure to pay close attention to “Good Morning, Captain,” which I’ve always loved. I was standing at a position that allowed me to see both the band and the audience, and so when the band hit the climax, I could see all these people in the front of the crowd screaming “I missed you!” along with Brian McMahan, which was pretty awesome.
GZA “Swordsman” – GZA’s performance of Liquid Swords was slightly shambling in the way that most rap concerts can be, but despite the gaffs of his DJ and non-rapping members of his entourage (ie, the white guys on stage), he was characteristically focused, intense, and verbally nimble. Unshockingly, my favorite songs from the album were the highlights — the grim rocksteady of the title track, the conspiratorial “Living In The World Today,” and most especially the bitter melancholy of “Swordsman.” After he finished the album, he threw in “Crash Your Crew” from Beneath The Surface, plus “Reunited,” “Triumph,” and “Shimmy Shimmy Ya.” Ghostface did the same thing both times I saw him perform last year, so this makes me wonder if there’s a mandate from the RZA that all Wu shows must include those songs no matter who is on stage. (Click here to buy it from Amazon. Shouldn’t this album be on midprice by now?)
Sonic Youth – I’m going to come back to this at the end of the month because I’ll be seeing them perform Daydream Nation again in NYC, but a few things: I went into this most excited about all the songs from the record that I had never seen before in concert, and while those were all totally amazing, I had the most intense emotional response to “Eric’s Trip,” which I’d seen six times before, and “Jams Run Free,” which was an unexpected surprise in the encore. (The other two encores were the considerably less exciting “Incinerate” and “Reena.”) In the best way, this show wasn’t about nostalgia for me — it was more about the way a song I’ve known for 13 years has taken on a brand new meaning for me, and my sentimental bond with one of their most recent compositions. Also, I totally made the right call by getting up to the front of the audience for this set. People were flipping out, and it allowed me to be a lot less self-conscious than I would have been if I were around most anyone else.
Grizzly Bear – I only caught about 30% of their set, but I was pleasantly surprised despite my general indifference to their music. That said, they seemed to cycle between really good ideas and very drab moments.
Beach House – If I didn’t see them with my own eyes, I’m not sure if I would have noticed they were there. They were so quiet and ethereal that their music just seemed to float out with the breeze.
Battles – I wanted to see “Atlas,” but I skipped out on their set early due to distraction and boredom. Maybe some other time.
Fujiya and Miyagi – Not bad, marred by weak sound. I was talking to William Bowers through some of this set, and we realized how fun it can be to sing bits of other songs that steal the groove from “Hallogallo”– “Spiders (Kidsmoke),” “Be Sure To Loop,” “Jenny Ondioline” — over their little motorik tunes. Also, there was another song in their set over which you could sing most any INXS hit.
Mastodon – Yeah, I’m just not ever going to get into this stuff.
Clipse “Keys Open Doors” – Clipse were by far the highlight of the otherwise kinda blah second day of the festival. The duo were incredibly sharp and charismatic, and their set came across like the work of men who weren’t about to settle for being just okay. That’s kinda the core of their appeal — they go above and beyond in terms of effort and quality control, and care deeply about their craft in a way that resonates with me far more than a lot of other more mainstream rappers who act as though their starpower is a fait accompli instead of the foundation on which they build a catalog of airtight songs. (Click here to buy it from Amazon.)
Cat Power & the Dirty Delta Blues Band – I feel like a creep for saying this, but I liked Chan Marshall so much more before she cleaned up and started making brunch music. This set could barely hold my attention, though I should say that I was mildly alarmed by the way her new arrangement for “Satisfaction” seems to horribly misunderstand the reason why the one from The Covers Record was so fantastic in the first place.
Yoko Ono – A lot of people hated her set and left early. I had to leave early too, but I promise that it had nothing to do with Yoko. The intro with the flashlights was a bit tedious, but once she got going, it was pretty groovy and cool. I think I heard her doing “Walking On Thin Ice” from the El platform.
Deerhunter @ Pitchfork Music Festival 7/15/2007
Cryptograms / Wash Off / Dr. Glass / Spring Hall Convert / Hazel Street / Strange Lights (with guys from Grizzly Bear)
Deerhunter were quite good, but more than a little bit out of their element. They seemed even more frail and ethereal than usual, which wasn’t such a bad thing, though the most aggressive moments of the first two songs were certainly the highlights of the set. I’ve been trying to figure out who Bradford Cox reminds me of, and I think I’ve got it — he’s like a cross between Marilyn Manson and Courtney Love. If you doubt me, I refer you to this interview on Pitchfork in which Cox desperately tries to get Stephen Malkmus to talk about gay stuff because he’s basically a narcissist with a one-track mind.
Brightblack Morning Light “Star Blanket River Child” – Brightblack Morning Light’s album came to me at a time when I was definitely not interested in hearing anything quite so mellow, but it’s grown on me a lot in recent weeks. Their set at the festival didn’t seem to include anything from the record, though I did skip out after 20 minutes or so of something that sounded a bit like Herbie Hancock scoring a nature documentary. (Click here to buy it from Insound.)
Junior Boys – I really didn’t expect anything from the Junior Boys other than laptops and some passive droning, but they really stepped up and put on a strong show, mostly thanks to their ace drummer. I need to go back to that last record now.
Jamie Lidell – I missed most of this set, but I did get to see him do “Multiply,” albeit from the opposite side of the park. Nice.
Stephen Malkmus @ Pitchfork Music Festival 7/15/2007
Heaven Is A Truck / Blue Arrangements / unknown song – “find a place to build my home,” “you want to be free” / Us / Extradition / Loud Cloud Crowd / Spit On A Stranger / Walk Into A Mirror / Trigger Cut (with Bob Nastanovich) / In The Mouth A Desert (with Bob Nastanovich) / unknown song – “edge of infinity,” “suits of charcoal gray,” “shamrock justice” / We Dance
Pavement “Funky Bob/Heaven Is A Truck” (Live at the Palace, Hollywood, 9/16/1994) – There is no possible way that anyone who attended this festival enjoyed this set more than I did. It felt like a full-on endorphin blast, and I think I’m only just now coming off of that high. I’m actually quite glad that I never got a chance to speak to anyone else about this set, because I think that if I heard anyone say anything remotely negative about it, I would’ve gotten very, very angry and it would’ve ruined the experience a bit. I kinda figured that he would play some Pavement songs because he was alone and that’s how he usually handles that sort of thing, but I never knew what to expect from one moment to the next, and every song in the set aside from the two I’d never heard before came to me like the biggest, happiest surprise in the world. And then Bob Nastanovich came out! There’s a word for that, and that word is SKWEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE! Aside from making me manic with joy for several hours after it ended, this set provided me with a bit of important self-knowledge — I love Malkmus/Pavement more than anything else in music, and even a weekend that also included performances by Of Montreal, one of my favorite members of my favorite rap group of all time, Clipse, the New Pornographers, and the entirety of Daydream Nation could come anywhere close to the mind-exploding euphoria I experienced watching Malkmus and Nastonovich kick out a relatively half-assed version of “Trigger Cut.”
Of Montreal @ Pitchfork Music Festival 7/15/07
Suffer For Fashion / Bunny Ain’t No Kind Of Rider / Softcore / She’s A Rejecter / October Is Eternal / The Past Is A Grotesque Animal / Heimdalsgate Like A Promethean Curse / Chrissie Kiss The Corpse / Faberge Falls For Shuggie / The Party’s Crashing Us // All Day and All of the Night
Homoerotic Star Wars football, Rocky Horror Picture Show costume changes, gold catsuits, Kevin face-balloons, red applesauce. Of Montreal’s shows are always a freaky spectacle, but they ran wild with the potential of a large festival setting. The set itself was slightly awkward in terms of pacing — I was thrilled to finally get to see “The Past Is A Grotesque Animal,” but its length nudged out several songs better suited to an audience comprised of several people who aren’t already fans of the group. I had a great deal of fun, but unfortunately this came immediately after Malkmus’ set, and couldn’t quite compare even though Hissing Fauna might be my favorite album from this decade.
The New Pornographers @ Pitchfork Music Festival 7/15/07
All of the Things That Go To Make Heaven and Earth / Use It / The Laws Have Changed / All The Old Showstoppers / Jackie Dressed In Cobras / The Spirit Of Giving –> We Will Rock You / Mass Romantic / My Rights Versus Yours / From Blown Speakers / Mutiny, I Promise You / Twin Cinema / Sing Me Spanish Techno / The Bleeding Heart Show // Slow Descent Into Alcoholism
No Neko, no Dan, no additional players. I guess the band likes NYC better? I probably would’ve been more into this set if I hadn’t just seen them two weeks ago, but c’mon, I’m always happy to hear “The Laws Have Changed,” “From Blown Speakers,” and “Sing Me Spanish Techno.” The thing is — well, I think somewhere along the line, the New Pornographers stopped being a fun party band, and just became a bunch of professionals who play great songs. There’s a magic spark that’s missing, and it’s been gone for a little while now.