April 20th, 2011 1:00am
Every Little Bit Of You And Me
The choice of singles from
Tusk is totally mystifying to me. I mean, I get that leading with "Tusk" is a show of hubris and that "Sara" is Stevie Nicks' personal favorite, but there just seems to be a lot of missed opportunities for radio hits. Of the Nicks songs, I would've gone with "Angel." As for Christine McVie, she didn't really come up with anything too compelling for the record, which is strange since she is otherwise the group's most reliable hit maker. Lindsey Buckingham's songs from this period have a reputation for being quite odd, but the truth is, he wrote the best candidates for singles on the record. It's a shame no one had the sense to give them a push.
In a catalog full of high quality break-up songs, "What Makes You Think You're the One" is almost certainly Lindsey's finest kiss-off. It's brutal and self-righteous and blind to its own hypocrisies. It's an upbeat, pleasant tune, but the rhythm is as agitated as it is peppy, and his voice takes on a strained, peevish tone. This song is essentially an expression of petty annoyance, and its perkiness comes out of the smug satisfaction of feeling like you've got the upper hand in an emotional conflict.
The soft rock hit that never was! "Walk A Thin Line" may be my favorite Buckingham composition. The most striking thing about the song is that it conveys this very powerful sense of isolation, but also this sort of clear-eyed confidence. It's the sound of a guy who totally believes that he's making the right decisions, no matter how precarious his position may be. He feels persecuted and judged by his peers, but he's too proud to back down. Instead he attains a gentle grace and embraces a patient outlook. The music approaches that laid back tranquility, but the high treble notes in his guitar betray a nagging doubt.
More Lindsey Buckingham tomorrow!
4/20/11 8:54 am
“Thin Line” is his “I Just Wasn’t Made For These Times”…”Tusk” probably has his best lyric efforts precisely because they’re so batty and abstract like a foreign movie or something…
4/20/11 9:45 am
What the hell are you being wrong about Christine McVie about for? Hm?
4/20/11 9:58 am
Are you trying to tell me there is a McVie song on the scale of “You Make Loving Fun,” “Everywhere,” “Hold Me,” “Over My Head” or “Say You Love Me” on Tusk?
4/20/11 10:06 am
“On the scale”? On what scale? Anyways, Over & Over, Think About Me, Brown Eyes, Never Forget. *drops mic*
4/20/11 10:09 am
I mean, Over and fucking Over, for god’s sake. At least you have to acknowledge that that song’s massive.
4/20/11 10:14 am
I refer you to two posts ago where I express deep confusion as to why anyone in their right mind would open a record with “Over and Over.”
They’re not bad songs by any stretch! They’re just not her best work.
4/20/11 10:25 am
Man, if you don’t get it, you don’t get it. Your loss. You don’t actually enjoy the album.
4/20/11 12:48 pm
My favorite thing about “What Makes You Think You’re the One” is the way he pronounces the words. It sounds like he’s so angry he can barely speak. It’s one of my gym songs, ha.
As far as the single selection on Tusk, I think it makes sense in the vein of trying to present the album as being similar or having the approachability of their others, which is deceptive, because it isn’t. But there are definitely better songs they could’ve used to convey its appeal.
4/20/11 4:12 pm
I’ve never heard ‘What Makes You Think You’re the One’ and if I hadn’t gotten it from here there would have been little doubt in my mind that it was Arcade Fire.
4/22/11 1:04 pm
I like “Over and Over” and “Think About It” but I agree they’re not McVie’s strongest work. On the other hand, I really like “Sara” even though I’m not generally a big fan of Nicks - it’s probably my second favorite of hers, behind “Dreams.”
Really, though, the Buckingham material on Tusk would be a great single album, and it’s let down a little by the other two songwriters’ material. “Walk a Thin Line” is one of the greatest songs ever, and “I Know I’m Not Wrong” isn’t too far behind.
4/22/11 1:38 pm
I feel Christine has some really solid tracks here, but agree that she doesn’t quite reach the heights of Buckingham (I Know I’m Not Wrong, Tusk, Walk a Thin Line) or Nicks (Storms, Sara, Beautiful Child). That said, her presence on the album is so perfectly soothing at the right times and perfectly bridges the other two songwriters’ material.
4/22/11 2:11 pm
I listened to a lot of “What Makes You Think You’re the One” a lot when creating a mix over the Winter. Made me wonder if Fleetwood Mac was an influence on Modest Mouse. Isaac often sounds like Lindsey does in this song.